Lifelong Democrat Sheriff Quits the Party After Locals Told Him to Leave for Backing Rogers and James

Saginaw County Sheriff William Federspiel, a lifelong Democrat who has run his Michigan county’s law enforcement since 2009, has left the Democratic Party after endorsing Republicans Mike Rogers for U.S. Senate and John James for governor. In his own telling, he did not exactly choose to leave. He says his local party showed him the door.

“I actually walked away at the urging of the local party who went on Facebook and told me to leave immediately,” Federspiel told The National News Desk in an interview published October 14, 2026, describing what happened after he announced his support for Rogers and James.

A sheriff the voters kept rehiring

Federspiel is not a fringe figure who wandered off the reservation. According to his official Saginaw County biography, he took office as sheriff on January 1, 2009, after 25 years in law enforcement, including nearly a decade with the Cape Coral Police Department in Florida and 12 years as an officer with the Saginaw Township Police Department. He was first elected in 2008 with 72 percent of the vote and re-elected in 2012, 2016 and 2020, and he told The National News Desk he has been elected to five terms as a Democrat and has worked in law enforcement since September 1987. Before becoming sheriff, he served on the Saginaw City Council.

In other words, he is exactly the kind of Democrat the party used to brag about: a working cop who rose through the ranks and won elections in a county that is anything but a coastal enclave. He described himself to The National News Desk as “the conservative blue dog fiscally responsible sheriff that I am,” and said he had drawn “great bipartisan support from not only Republicans and Democrats, but independents alike.”

“The party of my parents and grandparents”

Federspiel’s explanation for the break is not complicated. He says the party moved and he did not.

“I’ve noticed in the last 18 years how my party has shifted, shifted away from traditional values, Christian values,” he said. On abortion, he was blunt: “I’m very pro-life, I always have been. And I used to be accepted in the Democratic Party.”

He said that if he were a lawmaker rather than a sheriff, he would have switched sooner, because “my views do not align with those of the ideological left that have taken over the party of my parents and grandparents.”

He also described the cold shoulder he got from fellow Democrats. “Some of them just kind of walked by me and politely looked the other way,” he said. As for the party’s leadership, Federspiel said they are happy that he’s gone and would prefer to have a “real Democrat” in the job.

He said the friction was not new. According to Federspiel, it became “intolerable” every four years, as party figures would “sneakily sometimes find somebody to run against me in a primary,” and leaders “did openly support another candidate in a primary against me.”

Crime and the Senate race

The endorsement that triggered his exit came in Michigan’s open U.S. Senate race, where Rogers, a former congressman and FBI agent, faces Democrat Abdul El-Sayed. For Federspiel, the deciding issue was public safety, and specifically early release from prison.

“I don’t believe people should be released early from prison if they’ve been convicted by a jury of their peers,” he said. “I believe they should do the time if they’re willing to do the crime.”

He said El-Sayed “has stated publicly that he would like to let people free from prison, early, early sentence releases,” and argued that the cost of that policy falls on ordinary people. “I want to talk about the victims here,” he said. “Every time they release people early, they create more victims.”

The National News Desk report did not include a response from El-Sayed’s campaign or from Democratic Party officials.

Asked why he did not switch sooner, Federspiel pointed to the nature of his office. “I’m a sheriff, so I don’t make legislative decisions. I don’t make laws,” he said.

Why this matters in Michigan

Michigan’s Senate and governor races are among the most closely watched contests of the 2026 midterms, and Saginaw County sits in the heart of the state’s blue-collar middle, the kind of place where elections are won or lost. When a longtime Democratic sheriff publicly backs the Republican ticket and cites crime and abortion as his reasons, it is a signal to the voters who used to share his party label.

Pro-life groups noticed. LifeNews reported on October 15 that Right to Life of Michigan President Amber Roseboom called Federspiel’s move courageous and urged pro-life voters to turn out ahead of early in-person voting that begins October 24 and the November 3 election. Roseboom also pointed to Planned Parenthood’s announced additional $1 million in spending in Michigan and Maine, according to the outlet.

The Democratic Party’s answer to a pro-life, tough-on-crime sheriff with a decades-long record, by Federspiel’s account, was a Facebook post telling him to get out. That is a choice. Parties that once made room for blue-dog Democrats in places like Saginaw are now treating them as heretics, and the voters who think like Federspiel are watching how he was treated.

The Democrats told a pro-life, lock-them-up sheriff to leave, and he did; they had better hope the voters who agree with him don’t follow him out the door.

More from The Rothman Report

Taco Bell Coworker’s Tip Stopped a Self-Described Neo-Nazi’s Alleged Plot Against an Aurora Hindu TempleParalympian Veteran Waited 5 Years for a Wheelchair Lift. She Says Canada Offered Her Assisted Death.Glenview Teen Shot Dead at Home: Sheriff Says Evidence Is There, Cook County Still Won’t Charge